Back to blog

Pros and Cons of Agency Nursing vs Casual Pool Nursing

January 14, 2024
Nurse in blue scrubs making a hospital bed. White sheets and curtains.

​Though we at First Choice Care absolutely love agency nursing, we know a casual pool setup is also a viable and often rewarding option for nurses. So which do you choose? Working out the pathway that is right for you and your family can take time, research, and many conversations with nursing friends over microwaved Tupperware meals. So to make it easier, we’ve done the leg work by exploring the pros and cons of both options so you can make an informed choice. But who really says you have to choose one or the other anyhow?

​

Pros to Agency Nursing


Greater work- life balance and flexibility


As an agency nurse, you are in charge of dictating when and where you’d like to work. Though you can’t simply create vacancies wherever you like, you can work closely with your nursing agency and with a clever roster request process, organise a working life that suits you and your family's needs.


If you don’t want to work the night shift - you don’t have to. If you want to work all morning shifts without feeling the pressure from your colleagues to pull your weight on the PM shift - you can. It should be noted though that the choosier you are with the roster, the more limited your chance of obtaining work.

​

Greater networking opportunities


When working in a range of different facilities and hospitals you are exposed to so much more. You get to have conversations and work alongside talented people you’ve never met, in new and exciting environments. Though this is possible in a casual pool as well, agency simply gives you more reach as you can work across a range of facilities.

​

Financial Rewards


As an agency nurse, you can certainly save your pennies quickly as the rate per hour is rather impressive in comparison to a regular nursing wage. But why the difference you may ask? Well, there is the unpredictability of shifts which plays a part, but the other important aspect is agency nurses cannot accrue sick/personal leave. To put it blankly, if you don’t work you don’t get paid.


Cons to Agency Nursing


Lack of set shifts


Agency nursing can be unpredictable. You can be called up in a minutes notice to start a shift 30 minutes away, whilst at the same time be cancelled even on your way to a shift. There are rules and regulations about canceled shifts you’ll want to know about to ensure you are getting paid adequately should the job be cancelled last minute.

​

The constant need to adapt to a new environment


For some agency nurses, this is not a con at all! They thrive in new environments and meeting new faces. It’s what keeps them motivated and prevents complacency. What do you think?

​

Pros to Casual Pool Nursing


Guaranteed work


When working casual pool, you’re entitled to a roster generally 4-6 weeks in advance, outlining the shifts in which you will be working. Though you won’t generally know where you are working (i.e the ward), you will know the time and length of the shift in advance.

​

Feel part of the team


As casual pool staff are working within the same organisation, they can quickly develop relationships even after just a few shifts of being allocated to the same ward/unit. Knowing you are going to see a friendly face during your next shift may be just the motivational lift you need to give your best nursing care.

​

Staff offers and discounts


These include but are not limited to, salary packaging, the use of the on-site gymnasium, discounted car parking, use of the staff health clinic, and attending the in-service education program.

​

Cons to Casual Pool Nursing


Limited say in where you want to work


As casual pool staff are allocated to work where there are vacancies, there is a chance that you’ll be allocated the same ward often, and you may not like it. Though I’m sure there is an opportunity to voice your preferences, it is the nature of casual pool nursing.

​

You may not be working with your friends


Your shift may at times feel like you are working for an agency. You may not know the environment, if you’ve never had a shift there before, and you may not have met any of the other nurses. This can feel a bit isolating if you’re normally surrounded with nurses you know and trust.



In summary, if you want freedom within your work where you have the opportunity to meet new people and experience a range of different environments, think agency nursing. However, if you’d like to know when your next shift is, have the ability to plan holidays, and potentially work amongst friends, the casual pool workforce may be calling your name. Remember, if you can’t decide, there is nothing stopping you from doing both for a period of time that works, then adjusting down to what you prefer!

​

Cheers,


Emma


Registered Nurse


Co-Founder The Other Shift


Theothershift.com

​


More articles

October 22, 2026
Choosing between agency nursing and permanent employment is an important decision for nurses at every stage of their careers.
October 21, 2026
This month, we’re celebrating Mark , a dedicated registered nurse working in aged care who has been part of the First Choice Care (FCC) community since its days as Carestaff. Over the years, Mark has experienced the organisation’s growth and evolution firsthand. He values the flexibility of agency nursing, the opportunity to work across different aged care facilities and, most importantly, the supportive team that makes him feel valued. Finding Flexibility and Support with First Choice Care When asked what he enjoys most about working with First Choice Care, Mark highlights the flexibility to choose shifts that suit his availability and the opportunity to experience different workplaces. “I get shifts that suit my availability and I enjoy the places I get to go.” He also appreciates the personalised support he receives from the allocations team, who understand that he works night shifts and take care to contact him at appropriate times so they don’t interrupt his sleep. For Mark, it’s these thoughtful touches and the team's willingness to understand his needs that make working with FCC such a positive experience. Finding Highlights in Every Shift For Mark, there’s no shortage of memorable moments. From visiting new and interesting aged care facilities to receiving appreciation from the people he cares for, he finds plenty to enjoy in his work. “There’s been a lot of highlights,” Mark shares, reflecting on the variety of locations he visits and the appreciation he receives from staff and residents at the aged care sites where he works. He also enjoys connecting with the allocations team, describing them as incredibly helpful and sharing how much their conversations can brighten his day. These experiences are a reminder that the rewards of nursing extend beyond clinical care. Building connections, feeling appreciated and working with a supportive team all contribute to a fulfilling career. The Importance of Getting the Details Right When it comes to advice for fellow nurses, Mark keeps it practical and straightforward. “Dot your i’s and cross your t’s.” For Mark, maintaining accurate notes and documenting everything is essential to good nursing practice. Thorough documentation helps nurses keep track of important information, maintain continuity of care and provide clear, accurate handovers to colleagues. It’s a valuable reminder that attention to detail is a fundamental part of delivering safe, high-quality care, no matter where a shift takes you. Why Mark Recommends First Choice Care Having worked with First Choice Care since its days as Carestaff, Mark has seen the organisation evolve over the years and continues to value the support it provides. “I would definitely recommend FCC. I’ve been with them since they were Carestaff and I’ve seen the business evolving the whole time. They are very supportive and a good organisation to work for. I always feel valued.” We’re proud to have nurses like Mark as part of our team. His commitment to quality care, appreciation for his colleagues and dedication to the little details that make a big difference reflect the values we’re proud to champion at First Choice Care. Thank you, Mark , for your continued dedication to aged care and for being such a valued member of the FCC community. Congratulations, Mark, our Nurse of the Month for September 2026!  Join Our Team If you’re interested in flexible nursing opportunities with First Choice Care, find out more here.
September 21, 2026
For many nurses, a career in healthcare is about more than where you work. It’s about the people you care for, the experiences you gain and the difference you can make in the communities around you.
More Posts